Section 764. Court-ordered consolidation; mediation; judicial hearing officer  


Latest version.
  • 1. If the governing body or bodies of local government entities  with a  duty  to  prepare  and  approve  a  proposed  elector  initiated
      consolidation plan pursuant to section seven hundred sixty of this title
      fail  to  prepare  and  approve  such  plan  or  are otherwise unable or
      unwilling to accomplish and complete the consolidation pursuant  to  the
      provisions of this title, then any five electors who signed the petition
      seeking  consolidation  may  commence  a  special proceeding against the
      entities pursuant to article seventy-eight of the civil practice law and
      rules, in the supreme court within the judicial district  in  which  the
      consolidated  local  government  entity  or  the  greater portion of its
      territory will be located, to compel compliance with the  provisions  of
      this article.
        2.  If  the court finds that the governing body or bodies attempted in
      good  faith  to  prepare  and  approve  a  proposed  elector   initiated
      consolidation  plan  but  were nevertheless unsuccessful, then the court
      may refer such matter to mediation pursuant to law, with costs  of  such
      mediation  to  be  borne by the entities in such proportion as the court
      shall determine based on appropriate factors  including  population  and
      the good faith efforts of the respective entities. If the governing body
      or  bodies  thereupon  prepare  and approve a proposed elector initiated
      consolidation plan conforming to the requirements of subdivision two  of
      section  seven  hundred  sixty  of  this  title,  then the provisions of
      sections seven hundred sixty-one,  seven  hundred  sixty-two  and  seven
      hundred  sixty-three  of this title shall apply as if the governing body
      or bodies had proposed such plan without the  benefit  of  court-ordered
      mediation.
        3.  In  all other cases, if the petitioners in such special proceeding
      shall substantially prevail, then the court shall  issue  an  injunction
      ordering  the  governing body or bodies of the local government entities
      to comply with  the  applicable  provisions  of  this  article.  If  the
      governing  body  or  bodies shall violate the injunction, then the court
      shall appoint a judicial hearing officer pursuant to article forty-three
      of the civil practice law and rules to hear  and  determine  an  elector
      initiated  consolidation  plan  for  the entities that complies with the
      provisions of subdivision two of section seven  hundred  sixty  of  this
      title.
        4.  The  final  determination  of  the  judicial hearing officer shall
      constitute final approval of the elector  initiated  consolidation  plan
      and  provide  such plan takes effect forty five days after the filing of
      such determination with the clerk of the court, unless a petition for  a
      permissive  referendum  is  properly  filed  pursuant  to  section seven
      hundred sixty-three of this title.
        5. In any proceeding pursuant to this section in which the petitioners
      substantially prevail, the costs of such proceeding, including the costs
      of any judicial hearing officer appointed pursuant to subdivision  three
      of  this  section,  shall  be  borne  by  the  local government entities
      proportionately, at the rate provided for in article twenty-two  of  the
      judiciary  law  and  regulations  promulgated  pursuant thereto based on
      appropriate factors, including, but not limited to, population  and  the
      court's  findings  regarding  the  good  faith efforts of the respective
      entities.
        * NB Effective March 21, 2010