Section 308-A. Fees and expenses in certain private nuisance actions  


Latest version.
  • 1.
      Definitions. For purposes of this section:
        a. "Action" means any civil action brought by  a  person  in  which  a
      private nuisance is alleged to be due to an agricultural practice on any
      land  in an agricultural district or subject to agricultural assessments
      pursuant to section three hundred three or three  hundred  six  of  this
      article, respectively.
        b.  "Fees  and other expenses" means the reasonable expenses of expert
      witnesses, the reasonable cost of any study, analysis, consultation with
      experts, and like expenses, and reasonable attorney fees, including fees
      for work performed by law students or paralegals under  the  supervision
      of  an attorney, incurred in connection with the defense of any cause of
      action for private nuisance which is alleged as part of a  civil  action
      brought by a person.
        c. "Final judgment" means a judgment that is final and not appealable,
      and settlement.
        d. "Prevailing party" means a defendant in a civil action brought by a
      person,  in  which  a  private  nuisance  is  alleged  to  be  due to an
      agricultural practice, where the  defendant  prevails  in  whole  or  in
      substantial part on the private nuisance cause of action.
        2.  Fees  and  other expenses in certain private nuisance actions.  a.
      When  awarded.  In  addition  to  costs,  disbursements  and  additional
      allowances  awarded  pursuant to sections eight thousand two hundred one
      through eight thousand two hundred four and eight thousand three hundred
      one through eight thousand three hundred three-a of the  civil  practice
      law and rules, and except as otherwise specifically provided by statute,
      a  court  shall  award  to a prevailing party, other than the plaintiff,
      fees and other expenses incurred by such party in  connection  with  the
      defense of any cause of action for private nuisance alleged to be due to
      an   agricultural   practice,   provided   such   agricultural  practice
      constitutes a sound agricultural practice pursuant to an opinion  issued
      by  the  commissioner under section three hundred eight of this article,
      prior to the start of any trial of the  action  or  settlement  of  such
      action,  unless  the  court finds that the position of the plaintiff was
      substantially justified or that  special  circumstances  make  an  award
      unjust. Fees shall be determined pursuant to prevailing market rates for
      the  kind  and  quality  of the services furnished, except that fees and
      expenses may not be awarded to a party for any portion of the litigation
      in which the party has unreasonably protracted the proceedings.
        b. Application for fees. A party seeking an award of  fees  and  other
      expenses  shall,  within  thirty  days  of final judgment in the action,
      submit to the court an  application  which  sets  forth  (i)  the  facts
      supporting  the  claim  that  the  party  is  a  prevailing party and is
      eligible to receive an award under this section, (ii) the amount sought,
      and (iii) an itemized statement from every attorney  or  expert  witness
      for  which  fees or expenses are sought stating the actual time expended
      and the rate at which such fees and other expenses are claimed.
        3. Interest. If the plaintiff appeals an award made pursuant  to  this
      section and the award is affirmed in whole or in part, interest shall be
      paid  on  the amount of the award. Such interest shall run from the date
      of the award through the day before the date of the affirmance.
        4. Applicability. a.  Nothing  contained  in  this  section  shall  be
      construed  to  alter  or modify the provisions of the civil practice law
      and rules where applicable to actions other than actions as  defined  by
      this section.
        b.  Nothing  contained  in  this  section shall affect or preclude the
      right of any party to recover  fees  or  other  expenses  authorized  by
      common law or by any other statute, law or rule.