Section 22-201. Legislative findings  


Latest version.
  • The  council  hereby finds that the
      fulton fish market, the center of New York's wholesale seafood  industry
      located in lower Manhattan, has for decades been corruptly influenced by
      organized  crime;  that  organized  crime's  corrupting  influence  over
      certain functions in the market, including  the  unloading  and  loading
      functions,  has  resulted  in  the  commission  of  numerous  crimes and
      wrongful acts there, including but not limited to physical  violence  or
      threats of violence, property damage, and thefts; that organized crime's
      corrupting influence over the market has fostered and sustained a cartel
      that  has  forced  seafood  suppliers  and  truckers  to  use particular
      unloading crews at fixed prices in an anticompetitive  scheme  that  has
      been  censured  by  a  federal  judge; that organized crime's corrupting
      influence has resulted in retailers parking on  city  streets  and  city
      property  nevertheless  having to pay high fees to private loading crews
      whose principal function  has  been  to  provide  "security"  for  those
      vehicles  and  their contents while retailers have purchased fish in the
      crime-ridden market area; and  that  these  corrupting  influences  have
      further  resulted  in  higher  prices  for  wholesale seafood than would
      otherwise have to be paid in the absence of this activity.  The  council
      further  finds  that  despite the repeated efforts of law enforcement to
      prosecute  crimes  there  and  the   presence   of   a   court-appointed
      administrator  for the market, the problem of organized crime corruption
      in the market has persisted. The council further finds that the market's
      businesses, including wholesalers,  seafood  deliverers,  unloaders  and
      loaders,  have  not  been  effectively regulated by the city in the past
      under existing laws  and  regulations  governing  public  markets,  even
      though  they  often  operate  on  city  property, albeit without leases,
      licenses and registration.  The  council  further  finds  that,  in  the
      absence  of an effective regulatory scheme, wholesalers have established
      a "gray market" in tenancies at rates in excess of those being  paid  to
      the  city  and  have  thus deprived the public of its rightful return on
      city property, and further,  that  unscrupulous  businesses  have  taken
      advantage  of  this  absence  of  regulation  to  engage  in  fraudulent
      practices,  such  as  the  creation  of  "phantom   wholesalers"   whose
      businesses disappear from the market before payment can be obtained from
      them  for  seafood  they  have  received  from  suppliers, and that such
      practices have discouraged suppliers from utilizing the market area.
        The council therefore finds and declares that in order to provide  for
      the  more  efficient and orderly conduct of business in the market area,
      to ensure that any such activities are lawfully  conducted,  to  promote
      the  economic vitality of the market and to protect the public interest,
      it is necessary for the commissioner of small business services to  have
      expanded  authority  to license and/or register businesses in the market
      area and to regulate the conduct of such businesses. In particular,  the
      council   finds   that,  in  order  to  achieve  these  objectives,  the
      commissioner of small business services should be  authorized  to  issue
      requests  for  licensing  proposals  to  provide  unloading  and loading
      services in the market area and, at his or her discretion, issue one  or
      more  unloading  and loading licenses based on the review and evaluation
      of responses received pursuant to such requests. In the  event  that  no
      appropriate  responses  are  received to such requests, the commissioner
      should be authorized to arrange for the  department  of  small  business
      services  itself  to perform unloading or loading services or to arrange
      that they be performed by a contractor or a designee of the department.
        The council recognizes  that  complaints  have  been  made  about  the
      conduct  of  seafood distribution activities outside the market area and
      finds further that the conditions which have given rise to corruption in
      the market area can exist in  other  areas  where  there  are  wholesale
    
      seafood  businesses  or  concentrations  of such businesses. The council
      also recognizes that representatives of such businesses have  threatened
      to  move  their operations elsewhere and that some may relocate to other
      parts  of  the city. The council thus finds and declares that it is also
      necessary for the  commissioner  of  small  business  services  to  have
      authority  to regulate seafood distribution in areas of the city outside
      the market area in which such seafood businesses may concentrate.
        Application of this chapter will enhance the city's ability to address
      organized crime corruption and to protect consumers and the many  honest
      business  persons  who  do  business  in  or with the market or at other
      seafood distribution areas. It is thus the council's intent  to  empower
      the  city  to  have  greater  regulatory  authority  over the conduct of
      business in the market and in other seafood distribution areas.